dispute resolution

Mediation vs Court – which is better?

When a dispute arises, many people assume that going to Court is the only way to resolve it. In reality, most commercial, property, estate and business disputes are resolved without a Judge ever making a decision.

One of the most common alternatives to Court is mediation. So, which option is better? The answer depends on the circumstances, but in most cases mediation should be seriously considered before proceeding to file an action in a Court.

WHAT IS MEDIATION?

Mediation is a structured negotiation process in which an independent third party (mediator) assists the parties to the dispute to reach a mutually acceptable resolution.

Importantly, the mediator doesn’t decide who is right or wrong and does not impose a decision. Instead, they help the parties identify issues, explore options and negotiate a settlement.

Mediations can occur:

  • before Court proceedings commence;
  • during litigation;
  • as a result of a Court order; or
  • as part of dispute resolution procedures agreed by parties beforehand in their contract.

If an agreement is reached at the mediation, the terms are usually documented in a binding settlement agreement.

WHAT DOES LITIGATION ENTAIL?

Litigation involves a Court or Tribunal determining a dispute according to the law and evidence presented by the parties.

The process will generally involve:

  • Pleadings (formal documents like Summons, Statement of Claim etc filed with the Court);
  • Evidence (Affidavits – formal sworn witness statements);
  • Subpoenas and Discovery (production of documents);
  • Interlocutory applications (for procedural orders or specific pre trial issues);
  • Hearing – where the Judge delivers a judgment.

Unlike mediation, a Judge makes the decision and the parties generally lose control over the outcome. Plus, the usual order is that “costs follow the cause” so if you lose, you pay the other parties’ legal costs as well as your own.

ADVANTAGES OF MEDIATION

Mediation offers several advantages to going to Court, including:

Lower cost – Litigation can be expensive. Legal costs can quickly increase as the matter progresses through pleadings, evidence, conferences and hearings. Mediation often resolves disputes before significant legal costs are incurred.

Faster resolution – Court proceedings can take many months or even years to reach a final hearing. A mediation can often be arranged within weeks and often are resolved in a single day.

Greater control – In mediation, the parties control the outcome. Rather than having a Judge impose a decision, the parties can negotiate a practical solution that suits their particular circumstances.

Confidentiality – Court proceedings are generally public. Mediation discussions are usually confidential and conducted on a “without prejudice“ basis, allowing parties to negotiate openly without fear that settlement discussions will later be used against them.

Preservation of relationships – Business partners, family members, landlords and tenants often need an ongoing relationship after the dispute is resolved. Mediation is generally less adversarial than litigation and may help preserve commercial or personal relationships.

COURT PROCEEDINGS CAN PROVIDE ADVANTAGES

Advantages of heading to Court, include:

A binding determination – Where parties are unable or unwilling to compromise, Court provides a final determination. The Judge’s decision is legally binding and enforceable.

Urgent relief – Courts can grant injunctions and other urgent orders where immediate action is required to protect assets, preserve evidence or prevent further loss.

Compulsory powers – Courts have powers that mediators do not. For example, Courts can:

  • compel the production of documents (Discovery, Subpoena or Notice to Produce);
  • require witnesses to attend (through Subpoenas or Notices to Attend);
  • make enforceable Orders; and
  • award damages and costs.

Establishing legal rights – Sometimes a party needs a clear legal ruling, particularly where an important principle or contractual interpretation is in dispute. In these cases, litigation may be unavoidable.

WHEN IS MEDIATION LIKELY TO BE BETTER?

Mediation may be particularly suitable where:

  • both parties are willing to negotiate;
  • the parties wish to maintain an ongoing relationship;
  • confidentiality is important;
  • the legal costs of litigation are disproportionate to the amount in dispute; or
  • a practical solution is more important than a legal victory.

Examples of where mediations can generally assist include:

It is important to understand however, that mediation and Court are not mutually exclusive. Many disputes commence in Court and are later referred to mediation. In fact, a large proportion of civil disputes settle at mediation after the parties have exchanged evidence and have a better understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of their respective positions.

Often, commencing proceedings can provide the leverage necessary to bring the parties to the negotiating table. The best approach depends upon the nature of the dispute, the issues involved and the attitude of the parties. Obtaining early legal advice can help identify the most effective strategy and may save considerable time and cost.

FURTHER INFORMATION

Contact McKillop Legal for further information regarding commercial disputes, litigation, mediation, debt recovery or dispute resolution, contact McKillop Legal on (02) 9521 2455 or email help@mckilloplegal.com.au.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Specific advice should be obtained for your individual circumstances.

Family provision orders

Under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), eligible persons may apply to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for a family provision order in relation to the estate or notional* estate of a deceased person to provide “for their maintenance, education or advancement in life”.

The first hurdle to overcome is being an “eligible person” and the second is whether the provision (if any) made for the applicant in the deceased’s Will** is adequate, and if not, what “family provision order” could be made to make it adequate. Unfortunately, this process is not as simple as we have explained it.

Limitation period

Claims for provision must be made within 12 months of the date of death of the deceased person (although in limited circumstanced, this time limit can be extended).

Process

After proceedings are commenced and the parties have put on the majority of their evidence, applications for family provision orders are generally referred to either a Court annexed mediation or to private mediation but if no agreement can be reached, the matter will be set down for hearing.

Eligibility

Those who are “eligible” to make a claim for a family provision order out of a deceased person’s estate include:

  • a spouse of the deceased at the time of the deceased’s death;
  • a former spouse of the deceased;
  • a person in a de facto relationship with the deceased at the time of death
  • children (including adopted children) of the deceased;
  • someone with whom the deceased was in a close personal relationship*** with at the time of their death;
  • those who have, at any time, been wholly or partly dependent upon the deceased and who either:
    • are a grandchild of the deceased; or
    • were, at any time, member of a household of which the deceased a member.

How do you know if you are to receive an inheritance?

Click here to read about how to get a copy of a deceased person’s will.

Adequacy

The Court won’t simply rewrite a deceased person’s Will based on claims of justice or unfairness such as unequally dividing an estate between siblings. The Court has a wide discretion in determining these matters and the nature of any order for provision that may be made.

The Court first considers if the gift (if any) was adequate and if not, what provision may be adequate.

The Court exercises is discretion to make an order and if so, on what terms, after considering the following factors:

  1. any family or other relationship between the applicant and the deceased, including the nature and duration of the relationship,
  2. the nature and extent of any obligations or responsibilities owed by the deceased to the applicant, to any other person in respect of whom an application has been made for a family provision order or to any beneficiary of the deceased’s estate,
  3. the nature and extent of the deceased’s estate (including any property that is, or could be, designated as notional estate* of the deceased person) and of any liabilities or charges to which the estate is subject, as in existence when the application is being considered,
  4. the financial resources (including earning capacity) and financial needs, both present and future, of the applicant, of any other person in respect of whom an application has been made for a family provision order or of any beneficiary of the deceased person’s estate (that is the competing needs/claims of others),
  5. if the applicant is cohabiting with another person–the financial circumstances of the other person,
  6. any physical, intellectual or mental disability of the applicant, any other person in respect of whom an application has been made for a family provision order or any beneficiary of the deceased’s estate that is in existence when the application is being considered or that may reasonably be anticipated,
  7. the age of the applicant when the application is being considered,
  8. any contribution (whether financial or otherwise) by the applicant to the acquisition, conservation and improvement of the estate of the deceased person or to the welfare of the deceased or the deceased’s family, whether made before or after the deceased’s death, for which adequate consideration (not including any pension or other benefit) was not received, by the applicant,
  9. any provision made for the applicant by the deceased, either during the deceased’s life or made from the deceased’s estate,
  10. any evidence of the testamentary intentions of the deceased, including evidence of statements made by the deceased,
  11. whether the applicant was being maintained, either wholly or partly, by the deceased before the deceased’s death and, if the Court considers it relevant, the extent to which and the basis on which the deceased did so,
  12. whether any other person is liable to support the applicant,
  13. the character and conduct of the applicant before and after the date of the deceased’s death,
  14. the conduct of any other person before and after the date of the deceased’s death,
  15. any relevant Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander customary law,
  16. any other matter the Court considers relevant, including matters in existence at the time of the deceased’s death or at the time the application is being considered.

*Where assets that were previously assets of the deceased prior to death (such as assets gifted or transferred by the deceased to another person or entity prior to death to attempt to avoid an application for an order for provision, superannuation, property owned as joint tenants between the deceased and another person), be considered as an asset of the estate for the purposes of an application for a family provision order.

**Note that even in intestacy (where there is no Will), an application can be made for a family provision order.

*** A “close personal relationship” is a relationship other than a marriage or a de facto relationship between two adult persons, whether or not related by family, who are living together, one or each of whom provides the other with domestic support and personal care but not for reward or on behalf of another person or organization.

FURTHER INFORMATION

For further information in relation to Wills, Probate, Intestacy, Estate Planning or even International Wills, please contact McKillop Legal on (02) 9521 2455 or email help@mckilloplegal.com.au 

This information is general only and is not a substitute for proper legal advice. Please contact McKillop Legal to discuss your needs.

Stay up to date – LinkedIn | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram